Signature A Sweet Memory cake on a pink backdrop
Signature A Sweet Memory cake on a pink backdrop
Signature A Sweet Memory cake on a pink backdrop
Signature A Sweet Memory cake on a pink backdrop
Signature A Sweet Memory cake on a pink backdrop
About us

A Sweet Memory Cake Shoppe is your go-to bakery at the Jersey Shore, where we specialize in custom cakes and desserts that capture the essence of your special occasions. Our bakery is known for its unparalleled creativity and attention to detail, from elegant wedding cakes to playful cupcakes. Whether you're planning a big celebration or a small gathering, our bakery offers a wide range of options to satisfy any sweet tooth. Visit us in Waretown, NJ, or give us a call to explore our delectable creations and book your consultation.

We are proud to be the house baker for Hotel LBI and we work closely with iconic wedding venues such as Parker's Garage, Surf City Yacht Club, Seashell Beach Resort, and Daymark just to name a few!

A happy couple with their A Sweet Memory wedding cake

4.8

Overall rating

1,021

Reviews across 4 platforms

70+

Cake flavors & fillings

6

Days a week, Tue–Sun

Shop categories

Custom cakes crafted to picture perfection — every size, flavor, filling and frosting, made for your celebration.

Gourmet, mini, jumbo and cocktail-inspired cupcakes baked fresh with only the finest ingredients.

Cake pops, truffles, Belgian chocolate trays and hand-decorated cookies — perfect favors for any event.

Elegant custom wedding cakes, cupcake towers and dazzling dessert tables for your big day.

High tea, à la carte lunch, showers and tea parties in our charming room of antique china and lace.

Cakes — A Sweet Memory categoryCupcakes — A Sweet Memory categorySweet Treats — A Sweet Memory categoryTea Room — A Sweet Memory categoryWedding & Events — A Sweet Memory category
Why us

Every cake tells a story, crafted with love and the finest ingredients.

Trusted by iconic Jersey Shore wedding venues.

Antique china, linens and lace — a charming escape in Waretown.

Treats designed to match your event's theme and colors.

Our tea room

Chef's choice, by the course

  • All-inclusive lunch package
  • Served on tiered trays
  • Reservations highly recommended
  • Perfect for celebrations

Tea room & garden patio

  • Baby & bridal showers
  • Milestone birthdays
  • Ladies groups & business events
  • Custom packages available

Order from our menu

  • Salads
  • Panini sandwiches
  • Scones
  • And, of course, tea!
Happy customers

★ 4.8 overall · 1,021 reviewsGoogle 4.7Facebook 4.8WeddingWire 4.7Yelp 4.0
IM
Delicious wedding cake! From the tasting to the our wedding day, they helped with our vision and delivered our cake to our venue. I would recommend!

Ian & Madison

Google review

Sweet moments

A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram
A Sweet Memory creation on Instagram

Stay connected with A Sweet Memory

Follow us for fresh creations, tea room events, seasonal treats and behind-the-scenes sweetness.

@sweetmemorywaretown ♥

Find us on Facebook
Weddings

Planning a wedding? Reserve a 60-minute cake consultation with Annemarie.

Loading calendar…
Good to know

A Sweet Memory Cake Shoppe is a beloved bakery located in Waretown. Our popularity stems from our commitment to crafting delightful, custom cakes and exquisite desserts that make any occasion memorable. As a bakery, we pride ourselves on using the finest quality ingredients to create a diverse array of treats. Our skilled bakers and decorators work meticulously to ensure that each creation is a masterpiece. Our bakery also offers a unique experience for our guests. It is the house baker for prominent venues like Hotel LBI and collaborates with iconic wedding spots. Our dedication to detail and flavor makes A Sweet Memory Cake Shoppe a standout bakery in the community. Visit us today to explore more about our offerings and make your next event a sweet memory. Experience the magic of our bakery and see why so many choose us as their go-to bakery for celebrations and everyday indulgences!

We specialize in creating stunning wedding cakes that mirror the dreams and desires of every couple. Whether you're envisioning a classic tiered cake or a modern cupcake tower, our bakery offers a plethora of design and flavor options. Our decorators work closely with you to customize each detail, ensuring your cake is both a visual and gustatory delight. From fondant finishes to buttercream dreams, our wedding cakes are tailored to make your special day unforgettable. Contact us to schedule a consultation, and let's create a cake that's a true reflection of your love story.

Ordering custom desserts is simple and exciting! To ensure we meet your expectations, we ask for a minimum notice of one to three weeks depending on the order's complexity and size. Our team will guide you through the process of selecting flavors, themes, and designs to perfectly complement your event. We offer a variety of bite-sized treats, cookies, and chocolates, all of which can be tailored to match your event's theme or color palette. Don't wait, contact us today to begin crafting your custom dessert experience.

Yes, we do! At A Sweet Memory Cake Shoppe, we provide dessert catering services tailored to suit events of all sizes. From weddings and corporate gatherings to intimate tea room events, our dessert tables are designed to dazzle your guests. We offer seasonal flavors and exquisite presentation, ensuring your event is both delightful and memorable. Our planners will work with you to create a menu that perfectly matches your vision. Reach out to us and let us cater your next event with our delectable desserts.

Absolutely! Our tea room is open to the public and ready to serve you a quaint and charming experience. You can enjoy a wide array of teas, along with our freshly baked pastries and desserts, without needing a reservation. Our tea garden offers a serene escape for both regulars and newcomers to enjoy. However, for larger groups or special occasions, we recommend contacting us in advance to ensure we can accommodate your party comfortably. Come by and relax with us today!

Get in touch

We can't wait to hear about your upcoming event. Fill out the form here and one of our team members will get back to you as soon as possible. We look forward to making your next event a sweet memory!

Annemarie, owner of A Sweet Memory, with one of her cakes
Watercolor blueberry cupcake

Handcrafted with love for life's sweetest moments

Plan your order